The Collyer Brothers: A Tragic Legacy of Hoarding
The tragic tale of the Collyer brothers stands as one of the most bewildering and distressing accounts of compulsive hoarding in history. Known for their obsessive collection of an unimaginable array of objects and their lives reclusive in squalor, Homer and Langley Collyer have become synonymous with the dark, isolating nature of extreme hoarding. Their story is a cautionary reflection on how obsession and mental illness can lead to an insurmountable downfall.
The Early Years of the Collyer Brothers
Homer and Langley Collyer were born into a prosperous and well-respected family in New York City during the late 19th century. Their father, Dr. Herman Collyer, was a distinguished gynaecologist, while their mother, Susie, hailed from an established and affluent family. The brothers grew up in a large brownstone mansion in Harlem, situated at 2078 Fifth Avenue, a location that would later become infamous for its horrifying state.
Homer, the elder of the two, was born in 1881, followed by Langley in 1885. Both brothers were highly educated. Homer pursued a degree in law, while Langley showed a keen interest in engineering and later studied music at Columbia University. The family was well-off and enjoyed the privileges of high society during their earlier years. However, their lives took a darker turn following a series of events that would thrust them into isolation and, ultimately, lead to their tragic demise.
The Decline into Isolation
The downfall of the Collyer brothers began with the dissolution of their family unit. In 1909, their father abandoned the family, choosing to live a life of solitude, eventually passing away in 1923. Following his death, their mother’s health began to decline, and the brothers, particularly Homer, became increasingly reclusive. In 1929, Susie Collyer passed away, leaving the brothers alone in the family home, which they inherited in its entirety.
Their withdrawal from society intensified after this point. By the early 1930s, the once respectable home had become an impenetrable fortress. The brothers began hoarding obsessively, bringing an extraordinary array of items into their home, including old newspapers, broken furniture, musical instruments, and a myriad of other seemingly useless objects. Langley, especially, had a bizarre belief that he could restore Homer’s health, after Homer went blind in the early 1930s, by feeding him a diet of oranges and untreated tap water. Langley would spend days gathering these items, even dragging back refuse from the streets of New York to stockpile within their walls.
Homer’s blindness and later paralysis only deepened their dependence on each other, with Langley becoming his sole carer. The mansion became their prison, with the windows and doors sealed shut, barricaded by piles of junk. The brothers refused to let anyone into their home, even turning away repairmen and utility workers, and as a result, they lived without heat, electricity, water, or phone service.
A Maze of Squalor and Madness
By the late 1930s, the Collyer brothers had become the subject of urban legend in New York. Rumours of their strange behaviour, their barricaded home, and the vast quantities of hoarded items spread through the neighbourhood. The brothers’ peculiar lifestyle attracted the attention of both curious onlookers and local authorities. There were occasional attempts to inspect the home, often resulting in Langley’s angry refusals.
Despite their secluded existence, they could not escape the interest of law enforcement and city officials. On several occasions, neighbours reported strange odours or vermin coming from the house, prompting health department inspectors to visit. The property had become a nightmarish maze of clutter, and the inside was described as resembling a hoarder’s labyrinth. Piles of boxes, newspapers, and other objects reached ceiling height, creating tunnels and passageways that Langley would crawl through to navigate the house.
In Langley’s increasingly paranoid mind, he feared intruders would attempt to break into their home and steal their possessions. To prevent this, he set up a series of traps made from the hoarded items. Some were as crude as piles of rubbish rigged to collapse if disturbed, while others were more elaborate, designed to catch potential thieves. This paranoia only served to further isolate the brothers from the outside world.
The Grisly Discovery
On the 21st of March, 1947, the police received an anonymous call claiming there was a dead body in the Collyer mansion. Officers arrived at the home but found themselves unable to gain entry. The doors and windows were completely blocked by walls of junk. It took several hours of labour to make an opening through a window on the second floor. Inside, they were met with a horrific sight.
After an extensive search, the police finally discovered Homer’s body. He was found slumped in a sitting position, emaciated and covered in filth, having died from starvation and dehydration. Langley was nowhere to be found, and at first, authorities suspected he had fled the scene. However, the search continued for days, with over 100 tons of rubbish being removed from the house.
Weeks later, on the 8th of April 1947, Langley’s decomposing body was found just 10 feet away from Homer’s corpse. In a grim twist of fate, Langley had been killed by one of his own booby traps. He had been crushed under a pile of debris while attempting to bring food to his incapacitated brother. Unable to escape or call for help, Homer had starved to death, unaware that Langley lay dead just a few feet away.
A Legacy of Tragedy and Infamy
The story of the Collyer brothers shocked the nation. The brothers’ obsessive hoarding and isolation, along with their tragic deaths, became the subject of intense media scrutiny. Newspapers across the country carried lurid headlines about the bizarre lives and deaths of “history’s worst hoarders.”
In the aftermath of their deaths, it took months to clear the mansion of the immense amount of rubbish that had accumulated over the decades. Among the items found were 14 pianos, a Model T Ford, a collection of firearms, and thousands upon thousands of newspapers. The brothers had even hoarded medical supplies, despite refusing medical help for their ailments. Ultimately, the mansion was deemed uninhabitable and was demolished shortly after the clean-up was completed.
The Collyer brothers’ tale remains a tragic testament to the devastating effects of hoarding and untreated mental illness. Today, their story continues to be referenced in discussions of compulsive hoarding, and they have even been immortalised in popular culture, appearing in books, films, and television shows. The name “Collyer brothers” has become shorthand for extreme hoarding, and their legacy remains one of caution and deep sadness.
The tragic saga of Homer and Langley Collyer illustrates how lives can spiral into ruin through obsessive behaviour and isolation. What began as a promising future for two intelligent and well-educated men ended in filth and tragedy. Their story serves as a stark reminder of the importance of mental health awareness and the potential dangers of unchecked hoarding. Although the Collyer brothers may have become infamous for their eccentricity and the ghastly condition of their home, beneath the sensational headlines lies the story of two men trapped by their compulsions, forever remembered as history’s worst hoarders.
Commentaires