Franca Viola: The Woman Who Defied Tradition and Rewrote Italy's History in 1966

In a time when societal expectations and laws seemed to conspire against women, one young woman stood up to defy the status quo, sparking a movement that reshaped Italian legal and cultural norms. Franca Viola, a name that might be unfamiliar to many, became a symbol of courage and progress for women in post-war Italy. Her refusal to submit to a brutal tradition that expected women to marry their rapists not only changed the course of her life but helped change the fate of many women in Italy. This is the extraordinary story of Franca Viola and her stand against a practice that, for centuries, had robbed women of their dignity and autonomy.

The trial had a wide resonance in Italy, as Viola’s behavior clashed with the traditional social conventions in Southern Italy, whereby a woman would lose her honour if she did not marry the man she lost her virginity to.

The Context: Sicily, 1965

In 1965, Franca Viola was just 17 years old, living in the rural town of Alcamo, Sicily. Her story began a few years earlier in 1963, when she became engaged to Filippo Melodia, a man eight years her senior and the nephew of a local mafia member. However, after Melodia was arrested for theft, Franca and her family made the brave decision to break off the engagement. In response, Melodia left for Germany, but not before vowing to return.

By the time he came back to Sicily in 1965, Franca had moved on. She was engaged to another man, Giuseppe Ruisi, a childhood friend who had captured her heart. Melodia, unwilling to accept her rejection, began to stalk and threaten Franca and her family. He was determined to force himself back into her life, believing that societal and legal norms were on his side.

The Abduction and Rape

On the 26th of December 1965, Melodia, accompanied by a gang of armed men, broke into the Viola family home. In a violent attack, they kidnapped Franca, beating her mother and dragging her away along with her younger brother, who was released shortly afterward. Franca was held captive for eight days, during which time she was repeatedly raped by Melodia.

Viola speaks to the police after being rescued from her captors.

Under the laws of the time, Melodia was confident that Franca would have no choice but to marry him. The infamous "matrimonio riparatore" (rehabilitating marriage) allowed a rapist to escape punishment if he married his victim. This archaic law was seen as a way to “restore” the woman’s honour and that of her family. In a society that placed enormous value on a woman’s chastity, the loss of virginity—no matter the circumstances—was considered a source of shame.

After Viola refused to marry her rapist, her family members were reportedly menaced, ostracised, and persecuted by most of the townspeople, to the point of having their vineyard and barn burned to the ground.

However, Franca Viola refused to be coerced. After her release on the 2nd of January 1966, when her father Bernardo pretended to negotiate with the kidnappers while working with the police, Franca made a bold decision. With her father’s support, she refused to marry her abductor, becoming the first Italian woman to publicly reject a "rehabilitating marriage."

Legal Battle and Cultural Revolution

Franca and her family’s defiance marked a turning point. By refusing to marry her rapist, Franca was not only rejecting Melodia’s advances but also the entire social and legal structure that had oppressed women for generations. She and her family pressed charges against Melodia, accusing him of kidnapping, rape, and intimidation. This decision did not come without consequences. The family was ostracised by much of their community, and their property was burned. But despite the threats and violence, they pressed forward.

Crowds of men attend a public debate about the trial.

The trial, which took place in 1967, became a national sensation. It was not just a legal battle but a cultural one, as the case brought to the forefront the question of whether Italian society could continue to condone a law that allowed rapists to go unpunished. Melodia’s lawyers tried to portray the crime as a consensual elopement, a common defence under the legal and social norms of the time. However, their efforts were in vain. In May 1967, Melodia was found guilty and sentenced to 11 years in prison. Several of his accomplices were acquitted, while others received lighter sentences. Melodia was released from prison in 1976, and was killed on 13 April 1978 in a mafia-style execution before he could return to Sicily.

Viola is shielded from the press during the trial.

The case attracted widespread media attention, sparking debates in Italian society about women’s rights and the need for legal reform. While Melodia's punishment marked a victory for Franca, the broader legal change came years later. The law that allowed rapists to marry their victims to escape prosecution, Article 544 of the Italian Penal Code, was not repealed until 1981. In 1996, Italy further advanced women’s rights by recognising sexual violence as a crime against the person rather than against "public morality."

Filippo Melodia and his accomplices await trial behind bars.

Change and Hope

While her courage in the face of adversity is undeniable, Franca Viola’s life did not end with her trial. She went on to marry the man she loved, Giuseppe Ruisi, in 1968. Their wedding was a public celebration, attended not only by local well-wishers but also acknowledged by national leaders. The President of Italy at the time, Giuseppe Saragat, sent a wedding gift to the couple, and Pope Paul VI invited them to a private audience.

Franca and Giuseppe had two sons and continued to live in Alcamo, the town that had witnessed her greatest trauma but also her triumph. Over the years, Franca’s legacy has only grown. In 2014, she was awarded the prestigious title of Grande Ufficiale dell’Ordine al Merito della Repubblica by President Giorgio Napolitano, a recognition of her role in the emancipation of women in Italy.

Franca Viola

---