The Diving Horse Shows: A Bizarre and Controversial Chapter in Entertainment History
In the late 19th century, one of the most peculiar and controversial forms of entertainment began to make waves across America: diving horse shows. These stunt-filled spectacles, which involved horses diving off towering platforms into pools of water, captivated audiences for decades despite raising serious concerns about animal welfare. The diving horse shows, however, were more than just a bizarre attraction. They represented a darker side of entertainment that favoured thrills over the safety of both animals and their human riders.
The Origins of Diving Horse Shows
The strange tradition of horse diving is credited to William “Doc” Carver, a man whose career as a sharpshooter with Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West show already had him in the spotlight. Carver was known for his impeccable marksmanship, but in the 1880s, he introduced something new to the world of stunt entertainment: the diving horse. Legend has it that in 1881, while crossing a bridge over the Platte River in Nebraska, the bridge collapsed, causing his horse to fall into the river. Whether the horse dived or simply tumbled into the water, this event supposedly inspired Carver to develop the dangerous act that would become his claim to fame.
The Origins of Diving Horse Shows
The strange tradition of horse diving is credited to William “Doc” Carver, a man whose career as a sharpshooter with Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West show already had him in the spotlight. Carver was known for his impeccable marksmanship, but in the 1880s, he introduced something new to the world of stunt entertainment: the diving horse. Legend has it that in 1881, while crossing a bridge over the Platte River in Nebraska, the bridge collapsed, causing his horse to fall into the river. Whether the horse dived or simply tumbled into the water, this event supposedly inspired Carver to develop the dangerous act that would become his claim to fame.
Carver began to train horses and riders for this death-defying stunt, travelling the country with his Wild West show. His son, Al Floyd Carver, designed the ramps and platforms from which the horses would leap, and Lorena Carver, another family member, became the first rider. The act soon gained popularity, particularly after Sonora Webster joined the show in 1924. Sonora, who would later marry Al Floyd Carver, became one of the most iconic diving girls in the act’s history.
One of the most famous shows was “The Great Carver Show,” which became a major attraction at Atlantic City’s Steel Pier in New Jersey. The sight of a horse, with a young woman clinging to its back, leaping from a platform as high as 40 feet, was thrilling for audiences but raised many eyebrows, particularly with regards to animal cruelty and the danger it posed to both rider and horse.
The Stunt: A Dangerous Dance
The mechanics of the stunt were as intricate as they were perilous. The horse would gallop up a carpeted ramp while the rider waited at the top, ready to mount as the horse passed by. Together, horse and rider would plunge into a tank of water, usually around 11 feet deep. It was an impressive display of both animal training and bravery on the part of the rider.
The horses were trained over time to take these leaps, gradually moving to higher platforms as they became accustomed to the stunts. When they hit the water, the horses would dive deep, their hooves touching the bottom before they pushed off to surface once again. Horses often threw their heads back to build momentum for the dive, which meant the rider had to be careful to keep their head to the side to avoid serious injury. Despite these precautions, riders often surfaced with black eyes, broken bones, and bloody noses.
While supporters of the show claimed that the horses were never injured, this assertion remains controversial. Animal rights activists argued that the repeated dives—sometimes four times a day, seven days a week—were undeniably stressful for the horses. The psychological and physical toll on the animals, though rarely documented, is difficult to dismiss. On the other hand, riders were more openly vulnerable to injury. Sonora Webster herself was famously blinded after a dive went wrong, but she continued to perform for many years afterward, becoming a symbol of resilience within the industry.
Popularity and Controversy
For decades, diving horse shows drew large crowds, becoming a staple of American amusement culture, particularly at venues like Atlantic City’s Steel Pier. But despite the shows’ success, they were never without critics. From the beginning, animal welfare advocates questioned the ethics of forcing horses to perform such dangerous stunts for human entertainment. While many claimed the horses were treated well and sustained no injuries, the sight of these majestic creatures being coerced into such unnatural feats raised red flags for many observers.
The popularity of the shows began to wane in the mid-20th century as attitudes towards animal welfare evolved. What was once seen as thrilling entertainment came to be viewed as an unnecessary form of animal exploitation. In 1978, the last diving horse show at Steel Pier was held, marking the end of an era.
A Revival and Resistance
In 2012, there was an attempt to revive the diving horse show at Steel Pier, sparking a fresh wave of controversy. Animal welfare groups, including the Humane Society, protested vehemently against the plan, launching petitions and campaigns to stop the return of what they saw as a cruel and outdated practice. Due to public pressure, the proposal was ultimately abandoned, ensuring that the diving horse would remain a relic of the past.
コメント